7 things you should know about c-suite recruitment in Islamic banking
Have you ever hired a senior leader who looked perfect on paper, only to find they could not navigate a Sharia board or win over a conservative investor? Recruiting C-suite talent for Islamic banking is not the same as hiring for conventional banks. You must balance commercial leadership, Sharia governance fluency, regulatory awareness and cultural intelligence. You also need a confidential, relationship-led process to reach passive, ready-to-move executives.
This article gives you a layered, practical guide to seven things you should know when recruiting C-suite leaders in Islamic banking. You will learn how to assess genuine Sharia experience, why hybrid skillsets are rare, how to reach hidden candidates, what local market nuance means for offers and timelines, and why digital and risk capabilities matter. I reference technical standards and regulators so you can validate claims, and I include real-life examples and actionable checks you can use in interviews, shortlisting and onboarding.
Table of contents
1. Sharia governance is non negotiable
2. The hybrid skillset is rare, look for depth and breadth
3. Relationship networks drive access to hidden candidates
4. Local regulatory and market nuance shape the hire
5. Compensation and total rewards, beyond base salary
6. Cultural fit and stakeholder management with Sharia scholars
7. Digital, risk and innovation competence defines future leaders
Start with this premise, which will frame every recruitment decision you make: a C-suite hire in Islamic banking is as much about credibility with scholars and regulators as it is about P&L delivery. Get the credibility wrong and you will face delayed launches, product reversals or reputational damage.
Get it right and you accelerate growth with a leader who can translate governance into competitive advantage.
1. Sharia governance is non negotiable
The basics
At C-suite level, compliance and governance must be Sharia defensible. Sharia rulings influence product design, documentation, revenue recognition and capital treatment. According to the Accounting and Auditing Organisation for Islamic Financial Institutions and the Islamic Financial Services Board, governance standards and supervisory frameworks are central to market confidence and product acceptance [AAOIFI](https://aaoifi.com), [IFSB](https://www.ifsb.org).
Intermediate insights
You should stop assessing Sharia experience by job titles alone. Ask candidates to walk you through specific instances where a fatwa altered a product or commercial strategy. Probe for the language they used with scholars and the trade-offs they proposed between commercial returns and Sharia acceptability. Request references who are actual Sharia officers or scholars, not just HR contacts. Technical questions on AAOIFI accounting rules and IFSB prudential standards will quickly reveal depth of knowledge.
Advanced insights
Case-based evaluation works best. Present a live or hypothetical scenario, for example: your bank plans to launch a retail sukuk-linked savings product in two jurisdictions, with differing tax treatment and Sharia interpretations. Ask the candidate to map the governance checkpoints, the potential scholar concerns, and a communication plan for regulators and investors. Look for answers that show the candidate can translate scholarly guidance into tradeable product terms and compliance checkpoints, and that they know where to escalate governance issues early.
Why this matters
A poor Sharia engagement strategy causes more than delay. It can force product redesigns, attract regulatory sanctions, and erode depositor trust. If a candidate cannot explain how a fatwa affected a past product rollout, they are probably not ready. For practical Sharia governance frameworks you can cite, see AAOIFI and IFSB for technical benchmarks [AAOIFI](https://aaoifi.com), [IFSB](https://www.ifsb.org).
2. The hybrid skillset is rare, look for depth and breadth
The basics
You will face scarcity. The ideal C-suite candidate combines conventional finance skills such as ALM, treasury, capital markets and risk, with demonstrated structuring experience in sukuk, mudarabah, murabaha or ijarah. Candidates who excel in one domain often lack rigorous exposure in the other.
Intermediate insights
Define the role as two converging skill streams, then weight them to fit your current strategy. If you are launching an Islamic window, you will prioritise product design and scholar engagement. If you operate an established Islamic bank, balance sheet management and growth expertise may matter more. Use competency matrices to score candidates on both streams.
Advanced insights
Use practical exercises in panels. For example, ask the candidate to draft a one-page market entry plan that aligns capital and liquidity management with Sharia-compliant product launches. Invite a Sharia adviser or senior product expert into the final stage, and include a scoring rubric that separates leadership, technical structuring and stakeholder management. If you must compromise, prefer candidates with rapid learning agility and a history of leveraging advisers, rather than those lacking scholar engagement experience.
Real-life example
A GCC regional bank hired an MD of Islamic banking who had strong treasury credentials but limited Sharia exposure. The bank implemented a three-month advisory pairing with a senior Sharia scholar and an external sukuk structuring consultant. That pairing accelerated launch-readiness and avoided a governance setback that had delayed comparable products elsewhere.
3. Relationship networks drive access to hidden candidates
The basics
Most high-calibre Islamic finance executives are passive. They are trusted by scholars, regulators and investors, and they move rarely. Generic job adverts will not reach them.
Intermediate insights
Retained, exclusive searches give you a confidential route into passive pools. You should map the market, identify candidates who meet your hybrid criteria, and approach them through trusted intermediaries, alumni networks and professional contacts. Warner Scott’s long-term engagement model demonstrates how specialist relationships surface candidates who remain invisible on public channels [recruitment trends 2025](https://www.warnerscott.com/recruitment-trends-2025-the-future-of-c-suite-hiring-in-finance-banking/).
Advanced insights
Confidentiality is currency. Limit interview panels, use NDAs for external advisers, and present a clear, compelling business case for the role that explains both the commercial opportunity and governance scope. Offer discrete exploratory conversations before formal interviews. If you are using an external partner, insist on a candidate confidentiality protocol and a market mapping deliverable that shows why selected candidates were approached.
Why passive candidates matter
The best leaders tend not to be looking. They often hold multiple informal advisory roles with regulators and families, and they will only consider a move if the role provides enhanced influence, board-level impact, or a significant strategic mandate.
4. Local regulatory and market nuance shape the hire
The basics
Where you hire matters. Islamic finance ecosystems concentrate in the GCC, Malaysia and Indonesia, with international hubs such as London and Singapore playing central roles in sukuk and capital markets. Regulatory expectations and governance arrangements differ substantially between jurisdictions.
Intermediate insights
Different markets prioritise different credentials. GCC markets often value localisation and relationships with local investors and families, while Malaysia frequently emphasises AAOIFI-aligned structures and institutional frameworks. International hubs focus on cross-border compliance and transparency. You should plan early for fit-and-proper tests, licensing, residency and tax implications. Bank Negara Malaysia and the Central Bank of the UAE publish formal guidance you can rely on for regulatory checkpoints [Bank Negara Malaysia](https://www.bnm.gov.my), [Central Bank of the UAE](https://www.centralbank.ae).
Advanced insights
Cross-border hires need a relocation and regulatory clearance roadmap. Use local counsel to confirm employment law and tax treatment, and plan for interim leadership if central bank approval is required for formal appointment. Where timing is critical, consider contract or interim appointments that allow the permanent hire to complete clearances without commercial pause.
Practical checklist
Verify licencing early, confirm whether the candidate needs local qualifications, prepare regulatory notifications, and build relaunch timelines that include scholar engagement and investor briefings.
5. Compensation and total rewards, beyond base salary
The basics
You must think holistically about compensation. A headline salary will not secure the right leader. For C-suite roles in Islamic banking, total rewards typically include regional allowances, long-term incentives and Sharia-compliant reward structures.
Intermediate insights
Typical package components include housing, schooling and repatriation benefits for expatriates, and long-term incentives or equity-equivalent vehicles for local executives. Performance metrics should align with Sharia principles, for example profit-sharing ratios and governance KPIs, not interest-based measures.
Advanced insights
When designing Sharia-compliant incentives, consult Sharia advisers early. Some banks use profit-share bonuses or sukuk-linked instruments that align with scholars’ views. Be explicit about vesting, clawback and governance-linked performance metrics to avoid disputes later. Present non-financial drivers such as role influence, board access and governance authority at the outset, since these factors often persuade passive candidates.
Practical negotiation tip
Discuss career path and succession planning early. Many senior candidates value the ability to shape strategy and governance as highly as immediate cash rewards. That clarity often turns a passive head into an engaged candidate.
6. Cultural fit and stakeholder management with Sharia scholars
The basics
Technical competence is necessary, but emotional intelligence will decide whether the hire succeeds. You need someone who can manage boards, Sharia scholars, regulators and major clients.
Intermediate insights
Test for stakeholder management skills in interviews. Ask for examples of disputes with scholars or boards and how the candidate resolved them. Seek language capability where appropriate, since multilingual communication matters in markets such as Malaysia, Indonesia and parts of the GCC.
Advanced insights
Run a board-simulation session. Replicate a scholar meeting and observe how the candidate listens, reframes concerns, and proposes compromises that preserve commercial value. Successful leaders show humility and patience, and they translate Sharia concerns into measurable commercial outcomes.
Retention through cultural fit
Design onboarding that gives the new leader time to meet scholars and regulators. Provide a dedicated internal Sharia liaison and schedule joint strategy sessions in the first 90 days. Set realistic short-term goals and formalise progress updates to the Sharia board.
7. Digital, risk and innovation competence defines future leaders
The basics
Digital transformation is not optional. Islamic banks must adopt digital channels and data-driven risk frameworks while preserving Sharia compliance.
Intermediate insights
Prioritise candidates who understand fintech, API-based architecture, cloud governance and data analytics. Regulators expect modern risk frameworks, and customers expect seamless digital experiences. Candidates must be able to show how they involved Sharia scholars in digital product design.
Advanced insights
Ask for delivery examples. Request a candidate explain a digital roadmap they led, the governance controls they applied, and how they mitigated Sharia risk in an agile environment. Review past track records on cybersecurity, data governance and cloud migration. If a candidate lacks deep technical experience, plan to recruit a senior chief digital officer who can partner tightly with the commercial and Sharia functions.
Warner Scott research shows that digital leadership is an increasingly decisive factor in executive selection for finance [unlocking exceptional c-suite talent].
Practical trade-offs
If a strong commercial candidate lacks tech depth, shortlist a credible CTO or head of digital as a mandatory hire within the first 12 months. Make the interdependency explicit in the role profile and in KPIs.
Key takeaways
– Prioritise demonstrable Sharia governance experience, not just titles, by asking for concrete examples and scholar references, and validate technical knowledge against AAOIFI and IFSB standards [AAOIFI], [IFSB].
– Build role profiles that weight hybrid technical and commercial skills, and use case-based interviews to test them.
– Use retained, relationship-led searches to reach passive C-suite candidates, and ensure confidentiality protocols are enforced. Specialist advice on market mapping and executive search is summarised in Warner Scott’s recruitment trends commentary [recruitment trends 2025].
– Factor jurisdictional nuance into timelines and offers, and verify licensing and regulatory approvals early through formal regulator guidance such as Bank Negara Malaysia and the Central Bank of the UAE [Bank Negara Malaysia], [Central Bank of the UAE].
– Design total rewards to be Sharia-compliant and aligned to long-term performance, and emphasise non-financial drivers during negotiations.
– Make digital, data and modern risk management a priority, and recruit technical partners if the chosen leader lacks deep digital experience.
Faq
Q: How do I verify a candidate’s Sharia experience?
A: Ask for specific examples of product approvals, fatwa negotiations and direct engagement with Sharia boards. Request contact details for Sharia officers or scholars who can verify the candidate’s role. Use technical questions tied to AAOIFI and IFSB standards to test knowledge. Conduct background checks focused on governance outcomes, not just job titles.
Q: Should I hire a conventional banker and train them in Sharia, or seek an Islamic finance specialist?
A: It depends on your timeline and risk tolerance. If you need fast, sophisticated balance sheet management, a conventional leader with rapid access to Sharia advisers can work. If you need deep product innovation under strict scholar scrutiny, a specialist is better. Consider an advisory pairing or an interim Sharia officer to bridge any gaps.
Q: How long does a typical C-suite recruitment take in Islamic banking?
A: Expect longer than a conventional hire. Regulatory clearances, scholar consultations and confidential outreach add weeks or months. A retained search can reduce time-to-hire by pre-qualifying candidates and managing approvals. Plan for a 3 to 6 month timeline, with additional lead time for cross-border moves and regulatory checks.
Q: How do I design incentives that are Sharia-compliant?
A: Avoid interest-based bonus structures. Use profit-sharing, equity-like sukuk instruments or governance-linked long-term incentives that scholars can endorse. Consult internal Sharia advisers when drafting terms and include clear performance metrics and clawback provisions. Test the plan with a Sharia board before offering it to the candidate.
Q: What is the best way to introduce a new C-suite leader to Sharia scholars and the board?
A: Create a structured onboarding plan that includes early introductions, joint strategy sessions and a clear schedule for scholar engagement. Provide a dedicated internal Sharia liaison and an external Sharia adviser if needed. Set short-term priorities that balance immediate wins with longer term governance work, and formalise regular progress updates to the Sharia board.
About Warner Scott Recruitment
Warners Scott is a premier global executive recruitment specialist based in London and Dubai, focusing on Banking & Investments, Accounting & Finance, and Digital & Fintech. With over 18 years of experience, they have built strong relationships with top-tier banks, financial institutions, and accountancies. Their unique value lies in these long-standing relationships with hiring managers and internal recruiters, a vast network of candidates, and continuous engagement. This combination places them uniquely in the market, trusted by both talent and hiring managers. Their evolved perspective allows them to precisely understand recruitment needs and pinpoint senior C-suite, EVP, SVP, and MD-level hidden, ready-to-move talent that other recruiters cannot access.
Warners Scott delivers tailor-made recruitment solutions for international and regional clients, functioning as true business partners. Their comprehensive services cover retained, exclusive, and contingency searches, as well as permanent, contract, and interim staffing.
In Banking and Investments, they partner with international and regional banks and investment houses in London and the Middle East, including conventional and Islamic banks. They cover areas such as Private Equity, Asset Management, Investment Banking, Treasury & Global Markets, Wholesale Banking, Digital & Technology, Risk Management & Compliance, and C-Suite Appointments.
In Accounting and Finance, Warners Scott works alongside The Big 4 and Top 50 accounting firms, along with globally recognised consultancies. They specialise in Audit, Risk & Compliance, Tax (Private Client, Expatriate, and Corporate Tax), Corporate Finance, Transaction Advisory, Restructuring, Turnaround, Insolvency, Forensic Accounting, Disputes & Investigations, Forensic Technology, eDiscovery, Cyber Security, and Management Consultancy.
In Digital & Fintech, they assist large banks, digital startups, and innovative Fintechs in areas such as FinTech (AI, Blockchain, Cloud Computing, Big Data), InfoSec/Cybersecurity (Application, Infrastructure, Network, Cloud, IoT securities), Digital Leadership, Digital Transformation, Software Development, IT Project/Program management, Data Science & Analytics, Data Privacy, and Data Architecture.